Abstract:Artificial intelligence systems are widely used to solve various challenges in the real world in an unprecedented way, and they have become the core driving force for the development of human society. With the rapid popularization of artificial intelligence systems in all walks of life, the trustworthiness of artificial intelligence systems is becoming more and more worrying. The main reason is that the trustworthiness of traditional software systems is not enough to fully describe that of artificial intelligence systems. Therefore, research on the trustworthiness of artificial intelligence systems is urgently needed. At present, there have been a large number of relevant studies, which focus on different aspects. However, these studies lack a holistic and systematic understanding. This study is a tertiary study with the existing secondary study as the research object. It aims to reveal the research status of quality attributes and practices related to the trustworthiness of artificial intelligence systems and establish a more comprehensive quality attribute framework for trustworthy artificial intelligence systems. This study collects, sorts out, and analyzes 34 secondary studies published until March 2022. In addition, it identifies 21 quality attributes related to trustworthiness, as well as measurement methods and assurance practices of trustworthiness. The study finds that existing research mainly focuses on security and privacy, and extensive and in-depth research on other quality attributes is fewer. Furthermore, two research directions requiring interdisciplinary collaboration need more attention in future research. On the one hand, the artificial intelligence system is essentially a software system, and its trustworthiness as a software system is worthy of collaborative research by artificial intelligence and software engineering experts. On the other hand, artificial intelligence belongs to human’s exploration of machine anthropomorphism, and research on how to ensure the trustworthiness of machines in the social environment from the system level, such as how to satisfy humanism, is worthy of collaborative research by artificial intelligence and social science experts.